Rabbi Yaier Lehrer

Thought for Shabbat

A weekly reflection from the Rabbi.

3 Kislev 5787

Parashat Toldot

Genesis 25:19 – 28:9 · Friday, November 13, 2026

Most of us know the story of Esau and Jacob. Before they are even born, we know that there is going to be trouble between the twins. Rebecca is uncomfortable with the fighting taking place in her womb. God tells her that there are two struggling nations in her womb. To make matters worse, each of the parents has a different favorite. So it is no surprise that Jacob tries to take advantage of the situation when his brother is extremely hungry and Jacob happens to be cooking.

But there is a big difference that most people don't focus on in Esau's response to Jacob's proposal of giving him a bowl of food for his birthright. The Torah tells us that after they complete the deal, Esau ate, he drank, he rose, he left, he “despised his birthright.” To some, Esau's actions are simply impetuous and have no malice. To others, Esau's actions are a clear, intentional abandonment of his birthright.

But whether it was because he was impetuous or intentionally abandoned it, Esau failed to understand the value of his birthright. Did Jacob take advantage of his brother? Probably. But Jacob could not have succeeded were it not for Esau's disregard for the value of what he had, what he gave up so cheaply.

People are in large part defined by what they value. It is what people value that determines their priorities and therefore their actions, inactions and words. Esau could have had the birthright but he didn't value or want it enough. As an example, for those who don't value their relationships or identity enough, they have a tenuous hold on both of those things because they don't see the need to work on them. This holds for relationships with loved ones, friends, strangers and even God.

Value is not always obvious. Sometimes we need to look for it in the various corners of our lives. The search itself helps us put the existing ingredients in our lives and perhaps leads us to the missing ingredient and how much of those ingredients we truly need. And in that search, we can also find out which things do not have real value. And perhaps in that search we can find who we really are and what we can be.

Shabbat Shalom

Rabbi Yaier Lehrer